Casey's General Stores, Inc. CASY
Composite 54/100; the shares have moved about 43% annualised. Names that move more contribute more risk for the same amount invested, and our composite reflects how strong the evidence for this one is right now.
Valuation ranks 26/100 — a moderate mark against it.
Growth ranks 72/100 — a moderate point in its favour. Momentum ranks 61/100 — a slight point in its favour. Balance-sheet strength ranks 60/100 — a slight point in its favour.
Valuation ranks 26/100 — a moderate mark against it. Income ranks 37/100 — a moderate mark against it.
What the company does Casey’s General Stores operates 2500+ convenience stores across 20 states, selling fuel, prepared foods (pizza, donuts, sandwiches), groceries, and consumer essentials. Its vertically integrated model includes 11 distribution centers supporting fresh food offerings and fuel margins.
Key financials ROE 19.1%, ROA 7.6%, ROCE 12.4%; gross margin 24.6%, operating margin 5.3%, net margin 4.1%. Revenue grew 10.2% and EPS 30.9% year-over-year. Strong balance sheet with Debt/Equity 0.74 and Piotroski F-Score 9/9.
Stock health 6-month momentum +12.04%, 12-month +54.20%, but -17.66% below 52-week high; RSI(14) 33.60 indicates oversold conditions. Sideravia scores: Quality 59.5, Growth 72.3, Strength 59.0, Valuation 22.4, Momentum 60.2, Income 35.9.
Price vs fair value Price is trading at a discount of 25.40% versus the analyst mean target of 957.39 (Barchart). - Analyst mean target implies 25.40% upside to current price (Barchart) - Food and grocery categories driving strong inside sales momentum (Zacks) - Texas football partnership raises brand visibility but keeps valuation questions in play (Simply Wall St.) - Simplified model flags potential 16% overvaluation based on cash flow strength (Simply Wall St.)
Looking forward Forward P/E 40.98 and PEG 4.59 suggest high expectations are already embedded in price. Analysts highlight inside sales momentum but flag valuation risks tied to growth investments and regional expansion.
This is not investment advice. Sideravia provides automated, data-driven analysis for information and education only. Nothing on this page is a personal recommendation or an invitation to buy or sell any security, and it does not consider your objectives or financial situation. Assessments are generated by rules applied uniformly to every covered stock — how our scores work.
Data as of 2026-09-05, compiled from third-party sources; errors and delays are possible and figures are not warranted. Investing puts your capital at risk; past performance does not predict future results. We publish our full track record, including the calls that lost, and our conflicts of interest.