AutoNation, Inc. AN
Composite 48/100; the shares have moved about 31% annualised. Names that move more contribute more risk for the same amount invested, and our composite reflects how strong the evidence for this one is right now.
Balance-sheet strength ranks 31/100 — a moderate mark against it.
Valuation ranks 71/100 — a moderate point in its favour.
Balance-sheet strength ranks 31/100 — a moderate mark against it. Growth ranks 37/100 — a moderate mark against it. Quality ranks 47/100 — a slight mark against it.
What the company does AutoNation operates automotive dealerships across the U.S., offering new/used vehicles, parts, service, finance, and insurance through Domestic, Import, Premium Luxury, and AutoNation Finance segments.
Key financials AutoNation reports strong returns: ROE 29.3%, ROA 5.9%, ROCE 14.8%. Margins are tight: gross 18.0%, operating 4.7%, net 2.5%. Revenue fell -2.1% YoY, but EPS grew 31.5%. Leverage is high (Debt/Equity 4.71), with interest coverage at 3.86.
Stock health Sideravia scores AutoNation Weak (Overall 46.0): Quality 41.0, Growth 39.7, Momentum 33.0. The stock is -13.55% below its 52-week high and RSI(14) sits at 50.60, indicating neutral momentum.
Price vs fair value AutoNation trades at a **discount** of 56.30% to our fair-value estimate of 318.65 and a **discount** of 18.93% to the 12-month target of 242.46. - Q2 earnings beat estimates despite revenue decline (Zacks, WSJ) - Analysts highlight strong returns but question growth (Simply Wall St.) - Sector peers miss earnings, adding pressure (Zacks)
Looking forward Forward P/E is 9.60 (PEG 0.54), suggesting valuation appeal. Analysts see potential upside to 242.46, but execution risks remain tied to new-vehicle sales trends.
This is not investment advice. Sideravia provides automated, data-driven analysis for information and education only. Nothing on this page is a personal recommendation or an invitation to buy or sell any security, and it does not consider your objectives or financial situation. Assessments are generated by rules applied uniformly to every covered stock — how our scores work.
Data as of 2026-09-05, compiled from third-party sources; errors and delays are possible and figures are not warranted. Investing puts your capital at risk; past performance does not predict future results. We publish our full track record, including the calls that lost, and our conflicts of interest.